How I Added 541 New Email Subscribers To My List In Just 48 Hours

By Matt Giaro

email-subscriber-growth

You know it.

Money is in the list.

But if you ever tried to build a list, you know how much of a grind it can be.

Write content, create lead magnets, yada, yada, yada.

Today, my list has over 5,000 subscribers.

But it hasn’t always been that way.

It took me 2 painfully slow years to build up an email list with around 1,000 subscribers.

Over the years, I found interesting techniques to add a lot of engaged subscribers (and buyers) to your list in a matter of hours.

The technique that you’re going to discover will not only help you attract a lot of subscribers, but most importantly also attract buyers — and those are the kind of subscribers that you want.

Is your content failing to attract Newsletter Subscribers?

Every time you hit publish, there’s a glimmer of hope.

Maybe this one will finally get some people onto your list?

But then… nothing.

You’re looking at your analytics, and the numbers shower you with a cold reality: your content isn’t connecting the way you hoped.

And the equation is simple: if nobody sees your content, then nobody can sign up for your email list.

It’s like you’re shouting into a void. You might be asking yourself what you’re doing wrong… You might even be doubting your expertise. Maybe your work just isn’t good enough? Maybe you’re wasting your time?

What’s the point of grinding out content if it doesn’t attract email subscribers?

Here’s the problem with most list-building techniques

Maybe you’ve tried creating daily content.

You bought into the narrative that if you just produced more, something would eventually stick. You tried it for a few days, until the motivation vanished and you gave up.

Or perhaps you’ve spent hours tweaking your SEO — obsessing over keywords, meta descriptions, and backlink strategies.

Maybe you’ve thought about pouring money into Facebook or Google ads to force your way into people’s feeds to finally kickstart that growth.

Or perhaps you tried social media and spent days crafting those perfect X/LI posts, following the templates, hoping it would go viral and bring a flood of attention your way.

But then what? All this writing for a handful of subs?

None of it translated into real engaged email subscribers that really build an income.

You might have the feeling of being stuck in thick mud.

I hear you.

But what you really need is a shift in focus.

Instead of chasing short-term metrics or trying to game the system, it’s about creating content that positions you for long-term discovery by the right people.

The one article that changed everything

On the 3rd of October 2023, I published another piece on Medium.

It got a decent number of views — nothing extraordinary.

Screenshot by the author

But it was out there, adding to my body of work.

A few weeks later, I received an email from someone who enjoyed my writing and asked a few questions.

At first, I didn’t think much of it. I replied as I generally do, and went on with my day.

But he stayed on my email list, reading my content. I had no idea who he really was — because he wasn’t using his “real” name.

Then, out of the blue, he reached out again, telling me he wanted to promote my work to his list:

Turns out, he had an audience of 24,000 engaged people.

An ordinary piece of content turned into an extraordinary opportunity.

Within 48 hours of his promo, I gained 541 new subscribers. And not just any subscribers, but engaged, interested readers, and most importantly… BUYERS.

Screenshot by the author

The brain hack to add hundreds of subscribers to your list overnight

The big idea here is simple: the more you publish, the more opportunities you create for discovery.

You’re not writing for likes or shares. You’re writing to be found by the right people at the right time.

It’s about putting in the reps, even when it feels like no one is watching because you never know who might be paying attention behind the scenes.

Take me for example: there are a handful of creators that I’ve been following for almost 10 years, but I never liked any of their videos. I didn’t reply to any of their emails, but I’ve been buying their products. I consider them my mentors even if I never met with them, so I’m the kind of silent superfan.

You’ll have your ounce of silent superfans too.

In a world where everything is tracked, it’s easy to get lured by the numbers.

Problem: Numbers don’t say everything.

These simple steps will help you get more subs (if you stick to it)

Shift your mindset from chasing external validation to finding fulfillment in the act of creating itself.

Find joy in crafting, sharing, and distilling your thoughts.

This way, writing and publishing become rewarding in their own right, not just because of the potential for likes or shares, but because you’re engaged in something you enjoy.

Then, pick a platform where you enjoy creating.

One of the mistakes that I made in the past was that I was constantly chasing trends: I was doing YouTube because YouTube was in. I tried to post on Twitter. I thought that Twitter was the place to go because everyone is on Twitter, and so on and forth.

As a result, I burned out.

Instead of making the same stupid mistake, don’t be a sheep. Choose a way of sharing your content that you enjoy within itself.

I love writing articles: So I have no problem spending two hours a day writing an article. Others hate writing and thrive in front of a camera.

Your medium ain’t important. What’s important is you digging the process. I know you heard that 1,000 times before but let me say it for the 1,001rd time. When you enjoy the type of content that you are creating, it’s easier to stay consistent.

Consistency leads to opportunity.

Next, commit to a regular publishing schedule. Don’t worry about immediate results or how each piece will perform. Give your analytics the finger.

Your goal is to build a consistent presence.

Over time, this steady stream of content not only sharpens your skills but also increases the chances that your work will resonate with the right audience.

The real reward comes from the process — knowing that with each piece you publish, you’re building something bigger.

And if your content is good:

  • authentic
  • interesting
  • and valuable to your audience

Then people will start to notice.

Just to put things into perspective: The article that I published that landed me this joint venture was the 163rd article that I published on Medium.

1–6–3.

I didn’t give up after 5 days of posting “consistently” complaining about the algorithm.

The right opportunities will come, not because you chased them, but because your work naturally attracted them.

But for the opportunities to show up, you have to show up first.

Want to monetize your expertise with digital products?

Get my free course below

FREE 5-Day Email Marketing Course

How to Create Your Own Passive Income Machine with AUTOMATED EMAILS

🔐 Your Information Is Safe. You Can Unsub Anytime.